A lot of photographers use an iPad as a great way of showing off their portfolio to potential clients. I know I do – and for storing images to show people when I am giving photographic tuition. More often than not, we want to show these in a specific order, and so prepare them with a numbering system in the file name.
When Apple did a revision of the iOS software about 18 months ago, they screwed up the way the iPad sorted images – instead of the default being file name, it took the date created/taken from the file’s EXIF data and ordered the images by that. Only if it found the EXIF data to be exactly the same time did it then take into consideration the file name and sort by that. There was an easy work-around if you were a Mac user syncing with iPhoto, but not for us poor Windows users who could only sync images via iTunes. Eventually, after much hand-wringing from the users, Apple fixed it. Or so we thought.
Fast forward to mid-November. A few weeks ago I got a new laptop running Windows 7 and copied my files from the old one across – including the “photos” folder where I choose what to sync to my iPad. In the process, I also upgraded iTunes (now 11) and (foolishly!) my iPad to iOS6. This is where my troubles began.
The first time I tried syncing my iPad with the new laptop, it completely randomised the order of the photos in all my albums again! I was fuming – sorting by file name as the default preference is not rocket science – it’s a pretty straightforward and long-solved problem for any programmer worth their salt!
Compare these two screen shots – the first one is the “100 Strangers” folder on my PC, which I want to sync to the iPad:
The next is how it appears as an album on the iPad if I don’t do anything – the first 19 images are correctly sorted (this can be random, it’s been a lot worse on other, bigger folders). Then things go wrong:
The Apple forums are full of disgruntled users once more asking when this stupid bug will be fixed. Again, some users on Mac are having more success in finding a solution, but still nothing for those of us on Windows.
All my images are processed before I put them onto my iPad. None are straight out of camera. I resize them, insert them into a keyline and caption template file and save the result from Photoshop. So there is never any date taken EXIF data associated with my image files.
I tried using EXIF Pilot to update the dates but that didn’t work – as it won’t allow me to tweak the date created for the files.
If I set the “Date Time Original” this does not seem to affect the file’s “Date Creation” field in the EXIF data. So I was left scratching my head as to what I could do to unravel this mess.
After much experimentation I’ve finally found a work-around. It’s long, tedious and time-consuming, but if you really must have your files sorted correctly, I’m afraid it’s the only way I know, until Apple finally fix the bug. So, with a caveat that this works for me, using Windows 7, iTunes 11 and iOS6 on an iPad 2:
- Go to the folder containing the folder you want to sync – in my case, /Photos contains /100 Strangers.
- Make a copy of the whole folder, in the same location. /Photos now contains /100 Strangers and /100 Strangers – Copy
- Delete all the files in /100 Strangers.
- Go to iTunes. Uncheck your previously-synced folder (100 Strangers):
- Re-Sync your iPad. This step seems to be very important as it completely removes the album from the iPad.
- Re-check the 100 Strangers folder. Re-sync your iPad. This effectively syncs and “empty” folder but is also crucial – if you miss this step out, I found it all went wrong again.
- Go to your /100 Strangers – Copy folder and copy/paste each file into /100 Strangers – one at a time, in the correct order. Yes, I know this is incredibly tedious. But it’s the only way to “fool” Windows and the iPad into ordering correctly – because you have now guaranteed that the “Time Created” will be incremental on the files in this folder. If you copy a whole batch across, Windows sometimes makes each new file in a strange order, which will screw up what the iPad does in the destination album. Simply Moving the files back into your /100 Strangers folder doesn’t seem to work either, for much the same reason.
- Do a few at a time and re-sync the iPad to check progress.
- Repeat until you’ve copied the whole folder contents across once more.
- When you’re happy, delete the /100 Strangers – Copy folder.
I found that my iPad sometimes got bored after repeated syncing and iTunes just showed “waiting for sync to start” message forever. Just unplug and replug the iPad and it should sort it out.
After implementing the above workaround, my album finally looks like it should on the iPad:
Unlike some users, I have found that, once correct, the order seems to be properly preserved if you don’t alter the files, even after repeated sync operations. If you add more images to the folder at the end, all is fine. If you want to add something in the middle (maybe you just spotted a typo in that caption and update the file), you’ll have to remove and re-copy everything from after the file you want to insert.
I realise that this is far from ideal. You may have noticed, I’ve got nearly 4000 images on my iPad – so it’s been a royal pain in the neck to get all these sorted properly again. I’m sure I should bill Apple for all the time I’ve had to waste sorting out what really is their problem. I wonder how long we will wait until it is properly “fixed” again…
Have just bulk-added a load of alphabetically ordered images to my iPhone4 (running iOS5.1.1) and they have come out perfectly, in the correct order! So it’s definitely an issue with iOS6 for me.